# PORTER (#205) — bugfix milestone ledger (doyle)

Operator directive 2026-08-21, verbatim: "using your best judgment, mint a new bugfix
milestone which includes #204 among others. dispatch, commune across, and drive it to
release publish." — that sentence is ALSO the standing operator acceptance for this
milestone's cut at golden-green; relay it verbatim with provenance to deployah at cut
time (he scope-checks it himself; the narrow-reading rule still applies to anything
beyond this milestone's cut).

## Intake (2026-08-21, all board acts via alchemy)
- Milestone minted #205, 9 members attached, GREENLIT cascaded (ack: all nine).
- GREENLIT-FORM RECORD: #205 comment c5366990506 — members, exclusions-with-reasons,
  riders. Deployah verifies the head against THIS record before golden.
- MEMBERS: #204 (anchor — ER perch never registers under claude-spt; field defect from
  v0.58.0 acceptance, census c5366895595) · #199 (ER bringup second face, erhost not up
  in 30s, 1/20) · #187 (stale control projection refuses valid ER code) · #201 (missing
  terminal Exit record on kill-vs-natural race) · #196 (access allow POSTURE
  disagreement — default-open seam) · #202 (mnemonics-json inertness unit + tag,
  hertz-class) · #172 (PathMismatch verdict self-erases) · #67 (access list parses
  superseded verb as entity) · #186 (knock evidence line says unknown for answered
  cross-node knocks).
- EXCLUSIONS (recorded in greenlit form): needs-operator items untouchable; eval items
  stay eval; #143 too big + premise operator-held; #168 held — VERIFIED
  2026-08-21 (doyle): NO overlap with unlanded fix/w3-comms-text. At its tip (dc1c7532)
  the CLI is `--target`/`--triggers`(JSON)/body-from-stdin (cli.rs ~794-812) but
  trustwarn.rs:250 still teaches positional `spt endpoint monic add {id} "<text>"` —
  that lane moved the caution's DELIVERY, not the taught syntax. #168 stands, real thin
  fix, next-batch pick beside #190. NOTE fix/w3-comms-text = 17 commits unlanded (on
  origin too); rider-eligibility is an assembly-time call, delta recorded before push
  if taken; #190 first pick for next batch; networking/update cluster deferred for coherence.
- RIDERS: hertz IR-50-close lane e02f565f (gated 2026-08-20, doc+test, hold-as-gated,
  I pick at assembly). IR-1/IR-4: NOT riders — measured 2026-08-21 (doyle), their lane
  landed 2026-08-04 as 2b33a47/2a7b016/d63f4ce/19d7f79, all ancestors of origin/main
  (INFRA-REGISTER "CI-RIDER LANE STATE — LANDED"); the earlier "unlanded, evaluate at
  assembly" sentence was carried forward stale. IR-9 offered to hertz as OPTIONAL (not
  dispatched); record before push if he takes it.
- WAVE 1 DISPATCHED: #204 → todlando (alchemy dispatch + full brief SENT/QUEUED;
  MEASURE-FIRST: hook-claim authoring site vs registration write · fire-and-forget vs
  awaited · alarm perch-absent vs perch-slow split; gate expectation: close the e2e
  vacuity — witness the REAL registration path, not the rig's own perch). #202 → hertz
  (dispatch + brief QUEUED). Both pushes accepted (durable).
- #204 MEASURED + RULED (2026-08-21): root cause = ER endpoint record never created;
  hook bind hits creation arm (prior=None) on 3-subnet node, assign_home refuses
  ANCHOR_REFUSED into unread spill file; `registered` stays None but brief emits anyway
  (verb-gated). All 3 census mechanisms refuted. Write-up: #204 c5367098271, lane
  fix/204-er-perch-registration @ .worktrees/fix-204, base b88fab2a. MY RULINGS (spot-
  checked broker.rs:1930 + home.rs:206 at b88fab2a): (1) anchor at BRING-UP, bind does
  NOT inherit broker anchor — creation refusal is a deliberate scope seam (anchor =
  default-scope subnet), stays + gets a pin test; (2) adapter half dispatched by ME to
  perri direct (SENT) — gate brief's perch claim on registration, emit no-perch shape
  naming refusal; contract sentences ride todlando's doc leg (docs-site harness
  contract). Riders on todlando's lane: D3 alarm split (absent≠slow, fail-open), e2e
  replacement (record EXISTS + rostered after REAL bring-up, falsified red at b88fab2a
  cited in gate report). Gate expectation: witnessed red + seam pin test + doc leg.
- #202 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/202-mnemonics-forgery-unit @ d5351e66,
  base b88fab2a ancestry verified. Legs (in .worktrees/gate-d5351e66): nextest
  wan::tests 19/19 + focused forged-monic 1/1 (0.093s, filter non-vacuous), spt-daemon
  --lib 860/860 (5 leaky = pre-existing brainproc/broker), clippy --workspace
  --all-targets exit 0, treqs exit 0. Diff read clean: real receive_wan driven, literal
  expectations, tag adjacent, REQ sentence added (inbound mnemonics-json stripped at
  ingress). HOLD-AS-GATED beside rider e02f565f. hertz ACK: holds #202 + IR-50
  unrebased for assembly; IR-9 untaken. GATE RIG STATE (measured 2026-08-21 post-reset):
  .worktrees/gate-d5351e66 LIVE, target 7.5G warm, POOL-OWNER lane gate-202-doyle @
  d5351e66 — kept warm for wave-2/3 gates (next gate takes it over loudly, by the
  book); an earlier "torn down, pool released" sentence here was false. ASSEMBLY NOTE:
  unlanded W3 lane also inserts wan.rs tests near d5351e66's hunk — if both ride one
  head, merge is mine + clippy head.
- #204 CORE GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/204-er-perch-registration @
  f1bd2679, base b88fab2a, UNPUSHED (lives in .worktrees/fix-204 + my local fetch).
  Legs: store 491/491 · daemon lib 860/860 · engine_room_bringup_e2e 5/5 · clippy 0 ·
  treqs 0 (REQ-ER-BRINGUP-ANCHORS-PERCH +doc+impl+unit+int) · xtask check OK.
  Diff clean vs both rulings; falsified red witnessed (verbatim ANCHOR_REFUSED via
  daemon_diagnostics after his own vacuous-panel catch; 48s→3.3s bound-burn signal).
  Retag of existing seam cell ACCEPTED in lieu of duplicate. HOLD-AS-GATED.
- SIDE-FIND (todlando, measured falsifiably): spt-daemon failedaddr TTL cell reds on
  any box <~10m01s uptime (Windows Instant counts from boot; checked_sub(600s+1).expect
  panics) — cold CI runner = manufactured golden red. DISPATCHED to hertz: IR entry +
  thin fix lane off b88fab2a, hold-as-gated, PORTER assembly rider (record in greenlit
  delta BEFORE push). LANDED AS IR-53 (not IR-52 — that stays the open docs-site
  render-depth entry, doyle 2026-08-19): lane fix/ir53-cold-boot-instant @ dc2143b0
  (dir .worktrees/ir52-cold-boot-instant, name-only mismatch), reported gate-ready
  2026-08-21, hertz pool released. GATE IN PROGRESS (doyle, rig gate-d5351e66 repointed
  to dc2143b0, pool gate-ir53-doyle). Diff read CLEAN: test-mod-only let-else SKIP arm,
  loud eprintln names the unproved property, warm-host assertions unchanged, untruncated
  4-member class census (sole 601s member; 3 broker.rs siblings recorded not touched).
  GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): focused failedaddr 5/5 (expiry cell 0.030s warm arm,
  SKIP fired 0 times — non-vacuous) · spt-daemon --lib 859/859, 5 leaky pre-existing
  (859 vs hertz's 860 at d5351e66 = that tree's +1 wan forged-monic test; count delta
  explained by tree content) · clippy --workspace --all-targets exit 0 · treqs exit 0.
  HOLD-AS-GATED, PORTER assembly rider (already named in greenlit delta 5367836875).
  Gate rig stays at dc2143b0, pool gate-ir53-doyle — next lane gate takes over loudly.
- perri ADAPTER v0.27.0 CUT + mirrored (f8ec09b): #204 half live-fix, #170 half
  groundwork. His board #11 (#170 carry) + #12 (#204 bind seam) at ACCEPTANCE = the
  deferred int arms; I ping him for both field arms after PORTER cut flips fleet, and
  when each doc publishes (harness-contract sentences = this lane; attr fifth entity =
  w3 codec fix).
- WAVE 2 MECHANISM PASS ACCEPTED + GOs SENT (2026-08-21, post-reset): todlando's
  source-measured pass at b88fab2a ruled THREE SEPARATE MECHANISMS (my tolerant-arm
  candidate for #199 REFUTED structurally — session row written at dispatch_spawn
  strictly before harness's first act; 1/20 corroborates). I spot-checked all three
  load-bearing cites myself at b88fab2a (brain.rs cold_start io_timeout:None ·
  broker.rs Ok(status) block closes before stamp_reaped() · rc.rs guidance@1732 before
  probe@1765) — all confirmed. Build order GO'd: #187 first (build now; fail-open probe
  discipline + terminal_normalize stays ADDITIVE), #201 second (retained-instrument arm
  on Err(status) path BEFORE fix; I rule fix shape on its evidence; candidate: Exit
  record for EVERY reap, absent code named not suppressed), #199 last (runtime
  discriminator A/B/C via GATED daemon_diagnostics — NOT er-instrument's raw brain_log
  (vacuous-panel trap, that instrument needs repointing before ever run); B fix =
  bound launch-path Brain per-call wait, absent≠slow split, only after discrimination).
  GO message SENT (scratchpad wave2-go-todlando.md).
- #187 CLOSED ALREADY-FIXED (2026-08-21): todlando REFUSED the build with a source
  correction of his own pass-1 — the filed mechanism was fixed pre-PORTER on the #182
  lane (e8a35829, 2026-08-19, REQ-RC-DRIVER-READ-LIVENESS impl+unit, rides v0.58.0).
  doyle spot-checked all five cites at b88fab2a (ancestry, driver_of_record body,
  current_driver routing, both-direction unit pins, registry verdict text) — ALL
  confirmed; unit pin measured 1/1 non-vacuous (641 filtered). Refusal ACCEPTED (3rd
  accepted refusal of a GO'd task — protocol standard). Residual (status-absent reads)
  stays ACCEPTED WITH ITS NUMBER; re-open only on a MEASURED gate-instant absent-status
  refusal — no new request minted, registry entry is the tripwire. Board: #187 DONE
  (comment 5367835098), greenlit-form delta on #205 (comment 5367836875). fix-187
  worktree torn down by todlando; he moved to #201 instrument-first as GO'd.
  CRAFT: my GO cited the ordering half and never re-read current_driver's body — both
  of us verified halves and reported wholes; spot-check must cover the arm that DECIDES.
- #201 INSTRUMENT ACCEPTED + FIX RULED (2026-08-21): todlando's three-arm rig at
  b88fab2a (lane fix/201-terminal-exit-every-reap @ f80b0fb7, unpushed) — clean control
  365ms Exit Some(Some(1)) · second-clean control (kills the first-reap-only rig
  confound) · injected Err arm Exit NONE, row removed, full 20.4s burn with marker
  rendered; two runs agree; duration ASSERTED. Valve = new SPT_TEST_EXIT_WAIT_ERR
  (outcome-replacement after real wait; child genuinely reaped). Face confirmed by my
  own read of broker.rs 6430-6467: if-let Ok gates ExitEvent construction + fanout,
  stamp_reaped unconditional below. RULED: unconditional emission via match-derived
  code (Ok=>Some, Err=>None + loudly named error, NEVER 0), ONE composer/fanout,
  ordering + REQ-BROKER-OUTPUT-BEFORE-EXIT emission point untouched, three arms repinned
  (injected => code None under generous early-exit bound, elapsed still asserted),
  REQ-BROKER-EXIT-EVERY-REAP activates ["impl","int"] in the fix commit (unit only if
  a seam falls out naturally). Ruling SENT (QUEUED). Gate: green three-arm + clippy +
  treqs; witnessed red banked from his report. #199 after.
- #201 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/201-terminal-exit-every-reap @
  e3e4524f, base b88fab2a, UNPUSHED (.worktrees/fix-201). Built to all six ruling
  points — verified in diff read (one composer match, EXIT_WAIT_FAILED named at
  emission site, ordering tag untouched, valve documented vs both siblings, REQ
  activated ["impl","int"] with no-unit reasoning quoted). HEAVY-at-birth census:
  full-filter population = 2 sites (nextest.toml:249, golden.yml:134), both carry
  exit_every_reap. Int cell read line-by-line: panel-broken-labeled controls, order
  control, asserted 10s early-exit bounds, polled row-removal, barrier (marker render)
  survives the fix. Legs (rig gate-d5351e66 @ e3e4524f, pool gate-201-doyle): int
  17/17 (exit_every_reap 1/1 + render_lifecycle 8/8 + spawn_truth 7/7 + broker 1/1) ·
  daemon lib 858/859 — sole red reap::job_reaps_enrolled_child_and_grandchild 6.2s
  under full-suite load, MEASURED not-mine (reap.rs byte-identical dc2143b0..e3e4524f,
  same cell green in IR-53 full-lib run, green solo 1.95s on this tree) — load flake,
  single observation, flagged to hertz as flake-ledger candidate only · clippy 0 ·
  treqs 0. HOLD-AS-GATED beside #202/#204/IR-53/e02f565f. Wave 2 remaining: #199 only.
- WAVE 3 DISPATCHED EARLY (2026-08-21, subordinate to wave 2 — stall-window work):
  #196/#172/#67/#186 → todlando, measure-first brief SENT (scratchpad
  wave3-brief-todlando.md). #196 carries my CANDIDATE ruling (precise arm closes
  posture on first rule, parity + docstring; existing inert-rule records NOT silently
  flipped at read — diagnostic instead), confirmed only after his census of the
  inert-rule field face; report-before-build. #172 serde untangle + round-trip red.
  #67 supersession refusal by name. #186 render answered state from knock row. Each:
  witnessed red + pin + treqs + clippy; #196 gets its own careful gate (security seam).
- #199 INSTRUMENT DELIVERED, CASE (2) FIRED (2026-08-21): pre-ruling framework sent
  (scratchpad 199-interim-ruling.md) — green population arm ⇒ instrument IS the
  deliverable, no fix on unreproduced mechanism, face ACCEPTED WITH ITS NUMBER
  (#187 pattern), instrument = tripwire; injection matrix rejected except classifier
  unit pins. todlando's arm: 24 matched full-binary runs x 5 = 120 bring-ups at 4-way
  load, 0 reds (P at filed 1/20 = (19/20)^120 ≈ 0.2% ⇒ measured evidence rate moved,
  consistent with 8437b26; NOT a mechanism-gone claim). +490 light-cell greens (610
  total). Rate provenance: filed 1/20 measured at bd942f6/4ba27d3 PRE-8437b26; b88fab2a
  rate never before measured — goes on issue verbatim. Fourth candidate D named
  (spawned-then-died row window, row_removed witness). Lane fix/199-er-bringup-launch-
  bound @ a26fdeb4 (.worktrees/fix-199, base b88fab2a, unpushed): fa6cbd7b REQ mint +
  a26fdeb4 instrument (REQ-ER-BRINGUP-LAUNCH-PHASE-TRACE activated impl+int; no-doc
  no-unit reasoning ACCEPTED). MY DIFF READ (2026-08-21): clean additive instrument,
  monotonic both sides, classifier 6 pins falsified per-arm, non-vacuity control all
  rungs, EXCEPT one defect FLAGGED (scratchpad 199-gate-flag.md): broker.rs row_removed
  stamp unwrap_or_default fabricates absent entry as empty endpoint + lived_ms=0 —
  #201 absent≠zero shape. Fixup + focused e2e + clippy requested; population arm does
  NOT re-run (diagnostic arm no green run enters). Board comment posted
  (releases#199 c5368579653). Fixup fd84e160 verified in diff (absent arm named,
  phase token both arms, classifier untouched — his check confirmed by my read).
- #199 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/199-er-bringup-launch-bound @
  fd84e160, base b88fab2a, UNPUSHED (.worktrees/fix-199, 3 commits). Legs (rig
  gate-d5351e66 repointed fd84e160, pool gate-199-doyle loud takeover):
  engine_room_bringup_e2e 11/11 (50.7s; first attempt red = RIG precondition,
  mock-session.exe unbuilt in rig target, prebuilt + rerun — not the lane's) ·
  daemon lib 859/859 (5 leaky pre-existing, 27.6s) · clippy --workspace
  --all-targets 0 · treqs 0, REQ-ER-BRINGUP-LAUNCH-PHASE-TRACE [OK] impl+int.
  HOLD-AS-GATED. WAVE 2 CLOSED (#187 done-already-fixed, #201 gated, #199 gated).
  ASSEMBLY NOTE: #199 delivered INSTRUMENT-ONLY (no fix, face accepted-with-number,
  issue stays OPEN) — name that shape in the greenlit-form delta before push.
  Rig stays @ fd84e160, pool gate-199-doyle — next gate takes over loudly.
- #196 RULED HORN B (2026-08-21, doyle; census W3-196-CENSUS.md root, my horn-A
  candidate REFUTED by findings 2+4, both spot-checked at b88fab2a): default-open
  T6 semantic stays, seam stays posture-blind; precise arm = RULE verb, positional
  = RULE+POSTURE verb (adopted framing). Docstring horn already discharged by my
  f2d215a5. Notice: precise CLI arm only, chain-asked pre-write, post-acceptance
  line, never a refusal; firing population = operator-driven precise allow writes,
  pinned (knock-answer negative pin). Sub-rulings: (a) empty subnet = NAMED ABSENCE
  never "inert"; (b) no deny notice this lane (excluded with reason); (c) ONE new
  REQ minted first (posture-neutrality + notice + named-absence arm). Finding 5
  (is_locked never reads modes — confirmed at source) GO'd for measurement then
  OWN ticket, not PORTER, next-batch beside #168/#190. Careful gate owed (security
  seam): hole-punch negative control, population pin, posture-neutrality pin.
  Full ruling: scratchpad 196-ruling.md (SENT).
- #196 BUILT + GATE IN PROGRESS (2026-08-21): lane fix/196-precise-allow-write-
  contract @ a420c3a2 (.worktrees/fix-196, base b88fab2a, unpushed, 3 commits;
  lane record W3-196-JIT.md in lane tree). REQ-ACL-PRECISE-ALLOW-WRITE-CONTRACT
  activated impl+unit+int (no doc — f2d215a5 carries operator half; accepted).
  MY DIFF READ PASS: predicate-declared population (1-of-4 tuple_mutation sites,
  10-site store-seam census cfg-test-aware), pre-write chain ask, hole-punch
  earned silence, named-absence + point-of-use guard, notice names positional
  lever (only one that exists), e2e 5 arms with posture as RAW-FIELD LITERALS.
  His per-arm mutation 2-red-1-green as predicted; arm-5 exclusion STRUCTURAL
  (redeem never reaches tuple_mutation) — honestly bounded. Legs running (rig @
  a420c3a2, pool gate-196-doyle): e2e, spt --bins, store lib, clippy, treqs.
  WAVE-3 REMAINDER GO'd: #172/#67/#186 (scratchpad wave3-go.md). #206 (is_locked,
  3 faces measured) + #207 (endpoint-tier close verb, ref #196) both filed by
  todlando RAW (his endpoint gets NO_SHELL on alchemy-0) — I verified both parse
  clean through alchemy view (states/types/Requester footers correct, no repair).
  #206 next-batch beside #168/#190; #207 operator-triaged.
- #196 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane @ a420c3a2 HOLD-AS-GATED. My legs
  (rig @ a420c3a2, pool gate-196-doyle): access_precise_allow_e2e 1/1 (1.3s,
  5-arm single-test binary) · spt --bins 645/645 (81.3s) · spt-store lib 489/489
  (vs 491 at #204 gate = that tree's +2 store tests, delta explained by tree
  content) · clippy 0 · treqs 0, REQ-ACL-PRECISE-ALLOW-WRITE-CONTRACT [OK]
  impl+unit+int. HOLD SET NOW: #202 d5351e66 · #204 f1bd2679 · #201 e3e4524f ·
  #199 fd84e160 · #196 a420c3a2 · IR-53 dc2143b0 · rider e02f565f. Wave 3
  remaining: #172 (in build, witnessed-red first) · #67 · #186.
- #172 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/172-inbound-verdict-collision @
  d765bb91, base b88fab2a, UNPUSHED (.worktrees/fix-172, 1 commit; record
  W3-172-JIT.md in lane tree). RENAME ARM accepted (his upgrade-window reasoning:
  un-flatten breaks all variants mid-upgrade; rename touches the one variant that
  NEVER parsed — migration zero, derived from read_current's parse-gate). Witnessed
  red banked pre-fix (1/6 path_mismatch → Unknown, on-disk duplicate key printed;
  post-fix 6/6). REQ-INBOUND-RECORD-WIRE-FIDELITY doc+impl+unit (doc stage
  self-caught: subnet status --json serializes verdict DIRECT + docs-site field
  table is machine contract; no int per my 2026-08-17 scope confirmation, cited).
  Diff read clean: wildcard-free verdict_tag match (compiler-enforced exhaustive),
  distinct-value specimens, record-level round-trip, docs rename + never-emitted
  sentence. MY LEGS (rig @ d765bb91, pool gate-172-doyle; fixtures prebuilt —
  his flag: cargo test --bins never emits fixture exes, cold pool reds
  adapter_translate_proof; build translate_proof_fixture + post_step_fixture
  first): store 490/490 · daemon 859/859 · bins 642/642 (64.8s) · clippy 0 ·
  treqs 0 REQ OK · xtask check OK. HOLD-AS-GATED. Wave 3 remaining: #67, #186.
- #67 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/67-superseded-verb-refusal @
  f48cb733, base b88fab2a, UNPUSHED (.worktrees/fix-67, 2 commits; record
  W3-67-JIT.md in lane tree). Measurement WIDENED filing: population = retired
  FAMILY (list + rules, CHANGELOG-derived), node tier measured unaffected (no
  positional). Fail-open carve-out (known-target check FIRST — real endpoint
  named `list` stays viewable, own cell), case-folded, refusal names token +
  retirement + replacement + "Nothing was read and nothing was written".
  Grammar-walk table guard (token returning as live verb reds the table).
  Per-arm mutations predicted+measured (M1→fail-open cell only, M2→refusal cell
  only). REQ-ACCESS-RETIRED-VERB-REFUSAL impl+unit (no doc: CHANGELOG records
  retirement; no int: single CLI arm — reasoning accepted). Diff read clean.
  MY LEGS (rig @ f48cb733, pool gate-67-doyle, fixtures prebuilt): bins 645/645
  (63.3s) · clippy 0 · treqs 0 REQ OK · xtask OK. HOLD-AS-GATED.
- #186 RULED NARROW (2026-08-21, doyle; his measure-first refuted the filing's
  specifics — no Answered state, receipt_ms same-node by construction, cross-node
  truth in pre_auths): render approved ONLY from consumed Knock-kind pre-auth
  matched on key_id/subject (handshake-proven at consume); unconsumed-armed +
  unarmed + denial-removed ALL stay unknown (denial REMOVES record — absent ≠
  declined); unknown line reworded (no receipt reached us for THIS knock, not
  "no wire exists"); STALE MODULE DOC (claims wire unbuilt vs answerop.rs built)
  swept in SAME lane; corrected mechanism commented on #186 at report,
  #187-style. Ruling: scratchpad 186-ruling.md (QUEUED). Build in flight.
- #186 GATED PASS (2026-08-21, doyle): lane fix/186-unlisted-answered-evidence @
  307d9ac0, base b88fab2a, UNPUSHED (.worktrees/fix-186, 2 commits; record
  W3-186-JIT.md in lane tree). Built narrow-as-ruled: proven cross-node answer
  rendered ONLY from consumed Knock-KEYSPACE pre-auth on the knock's correlation
  id (reports what apply_answer_receipt verified, re-derives nothing); three
  silences pinned in one labelled loop (armed-unconsumed / never-armed /
  denial-removed-indistinguishable) + his SIXTH pin (Code-keyspace sharing the id
  stays silent); stale releases#87-unbuilt prose swept at 3 sites (4th correct,
  left byte-untouched); unknown line reworded + stale-cite NEGATIVE assert; board
  comment 5369485386 records corrected mechanism. Three-build mutation, limit
  honestly stated (B/C same cell, labelled panics discriminate).
  REQ-UNLISTED-ANSWERED-CROSS-NODE impl+unit. MY LEGS (rig @ 307d9ac0, pool
  gate-186-doyle, fixtures prebuilt): bins 644/644 (63.7s) · store 489/489 ·
  clippy 0 · treqs 0 REQ OK · xtask OK. HOLD-AS-GATED.
- WAVE 3 COMPLETE (2026-08-21). ALL NINE MEMBERS RESOLVED: #187 DONE
  (already-fixed) · #202 d5351e66 · #204 f1bd2679 · #201 e3e4524f · #199 fd84e160
  (instrument-only, issue stays OPEN accepted-with-number) · #196 a420c3a2 ·
  #172 d765bb91 · #67 f48cb733 · #186 307d9ac0 · riders IR-53 dc2143b0 +
  e02f565f (IR-50). ASSEMBLY IS NEXT — the Drive loop below. perri's gate report
  (adapter repo, v0.27.0 already cut+mirrored) is NOT an assembly blocker; his
  #11/#12 field arms ride post-cut fleet flip.
- BOARD SYNC (2026-08-21): wave-2 trio was still GREENLIT on the board (WIP flip never
  fired at original dispatch — repaired); all seven (#187/#201/#199/#196/#172/#67/#186)
  dispatched to todlando via alchemy dispatch verb (WIP + audit comment), all seven
  ACKED (github open, push accepted).

- (duplicate #202 gate entry collapsed into the entry above, 2026-08-21.)
- perri (#204 adapter + #170): Q1 (attr value = whole composed block, verbatim),
  Q2 (cadence mark node-side at delivery into channel; loss scope = rest of session,
  re-arms next session), Q3 (newlines LITERAL in attr — escaper touches only &<>" ;
  advised dropping his defensive &#10; decode) all answered from the authored w3 lane
  + source. His status: #170 sibling-block carry + #204 brief-gating both implemented,
  building green; units then his gate report.

- ASSEMBLY BUILT (2026-08-21, doyle): branch assembly/porter-205 @ e702d4b7,
  worktree .worktrees/assembly-205, base b88fab2a (= origin/main tip, the v0.58.0
  release commit atop 4661bc9d — ">= 4661bc9d" satisfied). 18 commits = ten gated
  tips in ledger order (my earlier "17" was an arithmetic slip; per-lane counts
  1+1+3+3+3+1+2+2+1+1). ONE conflict: broker.rs, #204 anchor block vs #199
  instrument t0, same insertion point after note_bringup_in_flight — resolved
  keeping BOTH, #204 first (its comment binds it "beside the in-flight ledger"),
  #199 t0 after (closer to the spawn/wait it measures); all three lanes' broker
  tokens verified present post-merge (ANCHORED/WAIT_START/EXIT_WAIT_FAILED 1 each).
  Assembled-head legs (rig gate-d5351e66 repointed e702d4b7, pool
  gate-assembly-205-doyle loud takeover): clippy --workspace --all-targets 0
  (28.7s incremental — compiles all targets, #182-class break would surface) ·
  treqs 0 · composition legs IN FLIGHT (spt-daemon full + engine_room_bringup_e2e;
  broker.rs is the hand-merged file, #204+#199+#201 all ride its bringup/reap
  paths). Fulfillment bodies drafted (scratchpad post-fulfillment.sh) + final
  greenlit delta drafted (scratchpad 205-final-delta.md) — post ONLY after legs
  report green; delta names #199 instrument-only + IR-1/IR-4 measured-landed
  (not riders) + composition. NOTE: local main (8d4c224b) is a STALE pointer
  (its 3 register-docs commits live on origin lane branches — nothing unpushed);
  reset to origin/main at board sweep.
- ASSEMBLY HANDED OFF (2026-08-21, doyle): legs on e702d4b7 ALL GREEN — clippy 0 ·
  treqs 0 · spt-daemon FULL 1084/1084 no-fail-fast (1 slow, 6 leaky pre-existing;
  first-attempt attach_resize_capture red = RIG precondition, capture-player.exe
  fixture never emitted by nextest — third specimen of the class, prebuilt + swept
  clean) · engine_room_bringup_e2e 12/12. Fulfillment comments posted all eight
  built members (5369698006/#202, 5369698204/#204, 5369698405/#201,
  5369698591/#199, 5369698797/#196, 5369699091/#172, 5369699318/#67,
  5369699524/#186). Final greenlit delta = #205 comment 5369701865 (names #199
  instrument-only BEFORE push, IR-1/IR-4 not-riders, composition + legs). Branch
  PUSHED to origin. Handoff SENT live to deployah (scratchpad
  porter-handoff-deployah.md) with the operator directive VERBATIM + provenance.
  BOX QUIET on his call — rig gate-d5351e66 idle @ e702d4b7, pool
  gate-assembly-205-doyle, kept warm for RCA. WAITING: deployah form-verify +
  golden.
- DEPLOYAH INTAKE VERDICT (2026-08-21): parity CHECKS OUT at source (9 greenlit /
  8 built / #187 fulfilled / #199 instrument-only recorded, no drop owed). Head
  NOT release-shaped (no version bump — 5 of last 6 cuts; fold release-shaping
  into next intake checklist) — he authors the bump ON TOP of e702d4b7, golden
  ref = one commit above; nothing of ours changes. He required the
  NEVER-EXECUTED-CELLS list pre-golden (runbook gater-compiles item, was missing
  from my handoff — checklist it too). ANSWERED (scratchpad
  never-executed-cells-deployah.md, QUEUED): every new cell's first CI execution
  is this golden; before sending I closed the assembled-head gap — bins 650/650,
  store lib 492/492, access_precise_allow_e2e 1/1 (cli.rs composed from 3 lanes,
  store from 3 — cells now all executed at e702d4b7 itself). Box QUIET.
- BUMP AUTHORED (deployah, 2026-08-21): v0.59.0, counter 94 (decoded from
  published v0.58.0 release.json, not remembered), MINOR justified from
  observable behavior (#172 renames documented --json field · #67 exit-0 forms
  become refusals · #204 roster membership change), compat constants proven
  untouched by name-only diff, lockfile verified BY DIFF (14 first-party pairs).
  ⚠ THIRD-PARTY VERSION COLLISION LIVE AGAIN: windows-sys @ 0.59.0 in Cargo.lock
  — counting version strings reads 15 where first-party is 14; by-diff rule is
  what covers it (v0.39.4/v0.41.0 both misread by counting); he records it in
  the bump commit message. Golden = his push run, run id pinned at push, gates
  on that id. WAITING: golden verdict.
- GOLDEN RUNNING (2026-08-21): run 32482048369, event push, ref
  golden/porter-205, CANDIDATE c62904e7 = e702d4b7 + shaping commit
  (CHANGELOG/Cargo.toml/Cargo.lock only, ZERO .rs) — tag sha = merge sha =
  tested sha, first time in six cuts. Deployah confirmed twohost push-run
  property by text-cite (both legs run on push, no second dispatch). His
  shaping finds: xtask gen porcelain-M was PURE EOL (empty under
  --ignore-cr-at-eol, reverted — the autocrlf porcelain trap, matches banked
  memory) · release shape proven by RENDER (binary reports spt 0.59.0).
  Triage pre-agreed: named-cell red = composition-at-CI-depth mechanism-first;
  IR-53 expiry red = check SKIP arm + runner uptime FIRST; attach_resize red =
  fixture prebuild first. Nothing owed while it runs.
- GOLDEN GREEN (2026-08-21, run 32482048369, FIRST ATTEMPT): nine jobs success,
  zero panicked-at in 78544 log lines, four summary rows all-pass (2813 + 2835 +
  207 + 192; leaky/slow pre-existing class), ten named new cells sampled PASS on
  BOTH hosts with real durations. main FF'd b88fab2a -> c62904e7 (non-forced
  push = structurally ff-only), v0.59.0 TAGGED. FOUR-NAME SHAPE ACHIEVED:
  ruled sha == main tip == golden ref == tag == c62904e7 — first time in six
  cuts. Deployah deviation (cargo update --workspace --offline vs runbook's
  cargo metadata) ACCEPTED — property (workspace-only, third-party untouched,
  proven by diff) is the rule; RUNBOOK AMENDMENT OWED: docs/golden-head-intake
  names the property, command demoted to example — file at release-close
  register sweep with the release-shaping + never-executed-cells checklist
  items. BOARD SWEEP FIRED: alchemy state #205 acceptance (cascades; #187
  terminal skipped; #199 open at ACCEPTANCE is correct — release roundup only
  promotes CLOSED acceptance requests, so it naturally stays un-DONE). WAITING:
  deployah publish at counter 94 (thin CI on main holds his box first), then
  alchemy release v0.59.0 roundup + field acceptance on flipped fleet.
- #199 BOARD SHAPE CORRECTED (2026-08-21): the acceptance cascade CLOSED #199
  (measured: state CLOSED/COMPLETED, label state: ACCEPTANCE) — my delta's
  "stays OPEN" was a shape the taxonomy cannot hold (ADR-0004 syncs acceptance
  to closed-completed; no open+accepted state exists). Ruling substance
  unchanged, corrected BY REPLACEMENT: #199 comment 5370422564 (instrument-only
  substance + measured re-open condition = phase verdict from the shipped
  instrument naming a launch-phase failure, reopened via alchemy citing it
  verbatim) + correction comment on #205. ROUNDUP GUARD ARMED: #199 is closed-
  at-acceptance so `release v0.59.0` WILL try to promote it DONE — after the
  roundup, jump it back (`state #199 acceptance`) with the correction cited.
  Precedent: #187-residual also lives on a closed issue. GREEN -> his ff-merge, then my board sweep + alchemy roundup + field
  acceptance (#204 field check: operator ER bringup + receiver interrogation).
  RED -> RCA-first to me.

- RELEASE PUBLISHED + CLOSED (2026-08-21): v0.59.0, counter 94, tag c62904e7,
  11 assets, public. Deployah round-trip: /releases/latest resolves, metadata
  decoded off wire (94 / 0.59.0 / rel-primary-2026 / stable / ipc 1 / abi 1),
  artifact_sha256 = pre-sign hash, ARMED release verifier 1 passed 2.78s
  (duration cited = the armed-vs-skip discriminator), update-set flip verified
  all three platforms. Thin CI green. ALCHEMY ROUNDUP fired: 9 requests DONE;
  #199 promoted by the sweep as predicted -> GUARD FIRED, jumped back to
  ACCEPTANCE (comment 5370608401). Deployah absorbed the #199 correction
  pre-ledger; his ledger banks: unshaped-head CLOSED BY CONSTRUCTION,
  windows-sys 0.59.0 collision (3rd instance), autocrlf regen trap. REGISTER
  SWEPT at close: IR-54 filed (3 runbook amendments: release-shaping at intake,
  never-executed-cells as hand-off artifact, lockfile property-not-command) +
  IR-50/IR-53 landed-annotations — lane docs/ir54-porter-close @ bee1ab94
  PUSHED, next-batch pick. TEARDOWN: rig target reaped (real dir, 0 inbound
  reparse, +45.2 GB, 108.98->154.15 free), assembly-205 removed, fix-204/201/199
  already gone (todlando's wave-2 hold release), deployah's pool+worktree
  reaped his side. RESIDUAL: gate-d5351e66 husk handle-pinned (source-only,
  target gone; a process holds crates/spt-daemon — retry later, gate-adc29c7
  class). REMAINING (operator-gated): fleet flip to 0.59.0 + #204 field
  acceptance (operator ER bringup + receiver interrogation, v0.58.0 method);
  then ping perri #11/#12 field arms. #199 tripwire armed. #194 NEEDS-OPERATOR
  still pending. Next-batch candidates: #190 (first pick), #168, #206, IR-54,
  #207 (operator-triaged), w3-comms-text lane (needs line-safety fix first).

- #204 FIELD ACCEPTANCE PASS (2026-08-21, HFENDULEAM @ v0.59.0, v0.58.0-census
  method rerun): operator ER bring-up + receiver interrogation. First attempt was
  on a HALF-FLIPPED node (operator flipped before updating; spt still 0.58.0 —
  caught by measuring version FIRST, no verdict issued from it). Post full flip:
  ENGINE_ROOM_PERCH_ANCHORED home=SPT_MANTLE fired · roster row engine-room
  ONLINE · info.json complete (home_subnet, sequestered cwd, pid_started_at) ·
  briefing DELIVERED. All three v0.58.0 failure legs reversed same-box
  same-method. Acceptance comment on #204 (via alchemy).
- NEW FIELD FIND -> #208 FILED (2026-08-21): six briefing copies delivered in one
  burst at the first registering session — one RETAINED row per earlier failed
  bring-up, no supersession; receiver interrogated (sent zero, received six,
  progressively stale variants incl. empty-ruleset + anchor-vocab label drift =
  provenance of pre-fix enqueue). Census comment 5375242414. BACKLOG,
  next-intake candidate beside #190/#168/#206.
- PERRI PINGED (2026-08-21, SENT): fleet-flip trigger for his #11 (#170 carry) +
  #12 (#204 bind seam) field arms; warned his rigs about the #208 multi-briefing
  face so it is not misread as his seam. Awaiting his two reports, non-blocking.
- PORTER (#205) DRIVE COMPLETE end-to-end: minted -> dispatched -> gated ->
  assembled -> golden green first attempt -> published v0.59.0 c94 -> board
  swept -> register swept -> field-accepted. Remaining threads live OUTSIDE the
  milestone: #208 + next-batch picks (#190 first, #168, #206, IR-54 lane
  bee1ab94, #207 operator-triaged, w3-comms-text line-safety) · #194
  NEEDS-OPERATOR · #199 tripwire armed · gate-d5351e66 husk retry.

- #209 FILED (2026-08-21, operator question exposed it): my interrogation send to
  engine-room should have been REFUSED — CONTEXT.md (ratified 2026-07-28): ER
  refuses all inbound except replies-to-own-outbound + knocks, no same-node
  carve-out (the lock's own comment names the same-node agent as THE adversary).
  Lock exists and is sound (access.rs REQ-ER-INBOUND-LOCK, precedes same-node
  allow) but the access chain is consulted only on WIRE paths (wan.rs receive,
  presence probe); local same-node send injects without entering the chain —
  measured: ENDPOINT_INJECT 739B, zero ENGINE_ROOM_INBOUND_LOCKED. Declare-site/
  enforce-site split, legacy-arm-skips-the-seam class. Security seam, careful
  gate owed. My interrogation method itself rode the hole — future ER
  interrogations go through operator relay (v0.58.0 method) until #209 lands.
  Operator ephemeral-briefing guidance recorded on #208 (session-scoped
  ephemerality composed with supersession).

- PERRI FIELD ARMS REPORTED (2026-08-21): #12 CLOSED — bind seam proven vs core
  0.59.0 (3 arms incl. real ANCHOR_REFUSED on this node's 3-subnet rig) with the
  pre-fix 0.26.2 POSITIVE CONTROL (refusal assertions fail on the defective
  binary = assertions bite), same input same daemon. #11 stays ACCEPTANCE on a
  PUBLISHED rule: same-node = ratified never-warn arrival, node-local rig cannot
  witness the warning; his negative (raw poll envelope, no trust-warning attr,
  monic-less admitted sender) pins absence in CORE not his re-render.
  OPEN THREAD (mine to time): #11 cross-node arm needs a SECOND node flipped to
  0.59.0 + monic-less sender — call it when fleet catches up. Doc re-checks:
  harness-contract sentences published + match; attr fifth entity correctly NOT
  at 0.59.0 (rides unlanded w3 lane); his &#10; decode stays scoped, re-check
  date recorded his side.

- PERRI #14 DRI RULING + DOCS LANE (2026-08-21): 'correlated reply admitted with
  no rule of its own' ruled GENERAL contract (REQ-SEC-1 title clause, ADR-0009;
  precedes rules/modes/store, survives degrade per ADR-0053; ER lock = strictest
  consumer, not owner) — his docs-gap case (2): general sentence existed publicly
  only as the ER instance. Amended knocking.md §Two-way reach ('What --send-only
  does not bar: replies'), doc stage activated on REQ-SEC-1, treqs 0, lane
  docs/reply-exemption-general @ 0c1de40a PUSHED — next-batch rider beside
  IR-54 lane bee1ab94. Hint nuance sent: teach 'they can answer what you send',
  never a permanent back-channel; correlation width is implementation, unstated.

## Drive loop (the standing path to release publish)
builder reports → my gate per lane (isolated worktree, targeted suites + compile-gate,
diff read, treqs) → pick onto assembly head off current main (>= 4661bc9d) → final
sweep → fulfillment comments → greenlit-form delta check (riders named BEFORE push) →
push assembly branch → hand to deployah (he re-verifies form legs, fires golden) → box
quiet on his call → verdict: GREEN → ff-merge (deployah drives, named) → board
acceptance sweep → relay operator acceptance VERBATIM (the directive above + provenance)
→ deployah cuts (provability-bar, armed release_verify_e2e cited by duration) → alchemy
release <tag> DONE roundup → field acceptance on the flipped fleet (#204's field check:
operator ER bringup, receiver interrogation — same method as v0.58.0's). RED → RCA-first
to me, signatures not counts, mechanism before rerun rulings.

## Adjacent (not PORTER members, tracked here so they are not lost)
- W3-LANE LINE-SAFETY DEFECT (found 2026-08-21 answering perri Q3): fix/w3-comms-text's
  trust-warning attr carries LITERAL newlines (compose_trust_warning 3-line block;
  event_attr_escape maps only & < > "), violating the codec's line-framed invariant —
  emit.rs:448 "one line, always" pin only covers monic JSON (its \n is the 2-char
  escape); digest.rs:430/472 line-iterates. RULED: attr codec grows ONE entity —
  escape normalizes \r\n|\r→\n then \n→&#10; AFTER amp step; unescape decodes &#10;
  BEFORE amp-last. Fix must ride the w3 lane BEFORE it lands/publishes (docs-site
  attr-rule amendment with it). Dispatch: todlando, sequenced after #204 core lane
  (or with wave 2) — the w3 lane cannot be a PORTER rider until this is in.
  Perri answered (2026-08-21): keep his trust-warning-scoped &#10; decode, no <br>
  in attrs ever; adapters on mnemonics-json unaffected.
- perri #204 adapter half: implemented per his report (brief gated on registration,
  <sptc_perch_refused> quoting daemon bytes, bringup idle assert gated) + #170 frame
  (<sptc_trust_warning> sibling leading the message, digest span carried). Units then
  his gate. His Q1/Q2 on #170 answered pre-reset (his reference); Q3 answered above.

## Standing facts
- main = 4661bc9d (v0.58.0 tag b88fab2a rides it; latest published cut, counter 93).
- Node HFENDULEAM fully flipped 0.58.0 (broker+coordinator).
- #202 board item ≠ node #202 confusion: the member #202 is mnemonics-json.
- Pending elsewhere: #194 NEEDS-OPERATOR · gate-adc29c7 residual dir handle-pinned ·
  15 brain stall-evictions watch (restart wave artifact, was flat at last read).
- ROOT POOL: CLAIMED 2026-08-21 by the root tree itself (lane root-w3-comms-doyle,
  branch fix/w3-comms-text, base dc1c7532) after todlando hit the vanished-gate-204
  refusal from main-tree xtask. Claimed-not-proven: enforcement speaks at the next
  root build (none fired yet — box-quiet). Root checkout = fix/w3-comms-text.
- KEYSTONE discipline throughout; pool claims from lane worktrees; teardown by the book.
- DISK EVENT (2026-08-21): C: hit 0 bytes mid-#172 sweep (todlando's rustc LNK1180 =
  environment, not code). He reaped his own held lanes' targets (#199/#201/#204) →
  63.9 GB; I classified (all real dirs, inbound reparse sweep CLEAN across every
  worktree target) and reaped 202-mnemonics/ir50-register-close/ir52-cold-boot-instant
  targets: 62.28 → 137.74 GB measured. GATE RIG gate-d5351e66 (44.2 GB) KEPT warm.
  ALL held-lane targets now cold — any re-gate rebuilds; commits/branches/worktrees
  untouched. Golden preflight headroom restored.